Skip Navigation
Skip to contents

Ann Occup Environ Med : Annals of Occupational and Environmental Medicine

OPEN ACCESS
SEARCH
Search

Author index

Page Path
HOME > Browse articles > Author index
Search
Colin Tomes 1 Article
The impact of body armor on physical performance of law enforcement personnel: a systematic review
Colin Tomes, Robin Marc Orr, Rodney Pope
Ann Occup Environ Med 2017;29:14.   Published online May 16, 2017
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40557-017-0169-9
AbstractAbstract PDFPubReaderePub
Background

The law enforcement officer profession requires performance of arduous occupational tasks while carrying an external load, consisting of, at minimum, a chest rig, a communication system, weaponry, handcuffs, personal protective equipment and a torch. The aim of this systematic review of the literature was to identify and critically appraise the methodological quality of published studies that have investigated the impacts of body armour on task performance and to synthesize and report key findings from these studies to inform law enforcement organizations.

Methods

Several literature databases (Medline, CINAHL, SPORTDiscus, EMBAS) were searched using key search words and terms to identify appropriate studies. Studies meeting the inclusion criteria were critically evaluated using the Downs and Black protocol with inter-rater agreement determined by Cohen’s Kappa.

Results

Sixteen articles were retained for evaluation with a mean Downs and Black score of 73.2 ± 6.8% (k = 0.841). Based on the research quality and findings across the included studies, this review determined that while effects of body armour on marksmanship and physiological responses have not yet been adequately ascertained, body armour does have significant physical performance and biomechanical impacts on the wearer, including: a) increased ratings of perceived exertion and increased time to complete functional tasks, b) decreased work capability (indicated by deterioration in fitness test scores), c) decreased balance and stability, and d) increased ground reaction forces.

Conclusions

Given the physical performance and biomechanical impacts on the wearer, body armour should be carefully selected, with consideration of the physical fitness of the wearers and the degree to which the armour systems can be ergonomically optimized for the specific population in question.


Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by  
  • Women’s body armor: A comprehensive review of design, performance, and ergonomics
    Dinesh Bhatia, Priya Jaswal, SK Sinha
    Journal of Engineered Fibers and Fabrics.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • When Peace Officers Are Killed: Profile of Fatal Felonious Law Enforcement Traffic Stop Encounters in the United States
    Summer M. Jackson, Michelle Rippy
    American Journal of Criminal Justice.2024; 49(1): 100.     CrossRef
  • Evaluating the Variability Between 20-m Multistage Fitness Test Estimating Equations in Law Enforcement Recruits
    Patrick Campbell, Danny Maupin, Robert G. Lockie, J. Jay Dawes, Vinicius Simas, Elisa Canetti, Ben Schram, Robin Orr
    Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research.2024; 38(4): 742.     CrossRef
  • The comfort and functional performance of personal protective equipment for police officers: a systematic scoping review
    Sean Hudson, Leanne Ridland, Joanna Blackburn, Leanne Monchuk, Karen Ousey
    Ergonomics.2024; : 1.     CrossRef
  • Relationships Between Strength and Power With the 74.84-kg (165-lb) and 90.72-kg (200-lb) Body Drags
    Matthew R. Moreno, J. Jay Dawes, Robin M. Orr, Joseph M. Dulla, Robert G. Lockie
    Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research.2024; 38(7): 1305.     CrossRef
  • U.S. Law Enforcement Officers’ Stress, Job Satisfaction, Job Performance, and Resilience: A National Sample
    Elizabeth A. Mumford, Weiwei Liu, Meghan S. O’Leary
    Police Quarterly.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Paramento Policial: uma revisão
    Mara Luiza Gonçalves Freias
    Revista Brasileira de Criminalística.2024; 13(1): 17.     CrossRef
  • Biomotor Abilities for Law Enforcement Officer Readiness
    Luís Monteiro, Vanessa Santos, Mark G. Abel, Emily L. Langford, Gabriel J. Martinez, Luís Miguel Massuça
    Applied Sciences.2024; 14(7): 3004.     CrossRef
  • Exploring the life contexts of patrolling police officers in the European Union – A scoping review
    Elin Granholm Valmari, Mehdi Ghazinour, Ulla Nygren, Kajsa Gilenstam
    Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy.2023; 30(5): 585.     CrossRef
  • Occupational injuries and illnesses among law enforcement officers, 2001−2019: Findings from the Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation
    Hope M. Tiesman, Srinivas Konda, Steven J. Wurzelbacher, Steven J. Naber, Wesley R. Attwood
    American Journal of Industrial Medicine.2023; 66(12): 1079.     CrossRef
  • Wearable Safeguarding Leather Composite with Excellent Sensing, Thermal Management, and Electromagnetic Interference Shielding
    Ziyang Fan, Liang Lu, Min Sang, Jianpeng Wu, Xinyi Wang, Feng Xu, Xinglong Gong, Tianzhi Luo, Ken Cham‐Fai Leung, Shouhu Xuan
    Advanced Science.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Effect of the Law Enforcement Duty Belt on Muscle Activation during Hip Hinging Movements in Young, Healthy Adults
    James W. Kearney, Megan N. Sax van der Weyden, Nelson Cortes, Orlando Fernandes, Joel R. Martin
    Journal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology.2023; 8(3): 99.     CrossRef
  • Preliminary Study of 3-D Dynamic Interactions Between Backpack and Bearer for Health Monitoring Using a Multiple Sensor Method
    Kunyang Wang, Lei Ren, Richard Jones, Chris Nester, David Howard, Guowu Wei, Zhihui Qian, Xuewei Lu, Di Zhao, Luquan Ren
    IEEE Sensors Journal.2023; 23(24): 31098.     CrossRef
  • Kevlar®, Nomex®, and VAR Modification by Small Organic Molecules Anchoring: Transfusing Antibacterial Properties and Improving Water Repellency
    Efrosyni Frousiou, Efstathios Tonis, Georgios Rotas, Anna Pantelia, Savvas G. Chalkidis, Nikolaos S. Heliopoulos, Antonia Kagkoura, Dionysios Siamidis, Angeliki Galeou, Anastasia Prombona, Kostas Stamatakis, Nikos Boukos, Georgios C. Vougioukalakis
    Molecules.2023; 28(14): 5465.     CrossRef
  • Physical Fitness and Psychosocial Profiles of Policewomen from Professional Training Courses and Bodyguard Special Police Sub-Unit
    Mariana Carrilho, Vanessa Santos, André Rasteiro, Luís Miguel Massuça
    European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education.2023; 13(9): 1880.     CrossRef
  • Effects of load carriage on measures of postural sway in healthy, young adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis
    Joel Martin, James Kearney, Sara Nestrowitz, Adam Burke, Megan Sax van der Weyden
    Applied Ergonomics.2023; 106: 103893.     CrossRef
  • Evaluation of physical health, mental wellbeing, and injury in a UK Police Firearms unit
    Eddie Bradley, Saeed Fayaz, Chris Farish, Morc Coulson
    Police Practice and Research.2023; 24(2): 232.     CrossRef
  • Ergonomic impact of prehospital clinicians using body armour: A qualitative study
    Duncan T. Ritchie, Christopher Doyle
    Applied Ergonomics.2023; 108: 103947.     CrossRef
  • Life contexts among patrolling police officers in the European Union, investigating environmental characteristics and health – A protocol for a scoping review and a systematic review
    Elin Granholm Valmari, Mehdi Ghazinour, Ulla Nygren, Kajsa Gilenstam
    Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy.2023; 30(7): 1135.     CrossRef
  • The effects of equipment carriage on functional movement quality among law enforcement officers
    Brandy Ramaj Jewett, Colin Tomes, Kristin Voigt, G. Monique Mokha
    Ergonomics.2023; 66(12): 2277.     CrossRef
  • Profiling the Typical Training Load of a Law Enforcement Recruit Class
    Danny Maupin, Ben Schram, Elisa F. D. Canetti, Joseph M. Dulla, J. Jay Dawes, Robert G. Lockie, Robin M. Orr
    International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2022; 19(20): 13457.     CrossRef
  • Physiological Demands of Common Occupational Tasks among Australian Police Officers: A Descriptive Analysis
    Amy Decker, Benjamin Hilton, Jay Dawes, Robert Lockie, Robin M Orr
    Annals of Work Exposures and Health.2022; 66(7): 960.     CrossRef
  • Auxetic Materials for Personal Protection: A Review
    Danish Tahir, Minglonghai Zhang, Hong Hu
    physica status solidi (b).2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Identifying the Physical Fitness and Health Evaluations for Police Officers: Brief Systematic Review with an Emphasis on the Portuguese Research
    Luís M. Massuça, Vanessa Santos, Luís F. Monteiro
    Biology.2022; 11(7): 1061.     CrossRef
  • Profiling the New Zealand Police Trainee Physical Competency Test
    J. Jay Dawes, Jordan Scott, Elisa F. D. Canetti, Robert G. Lockie, Ben Schram, Robin M. Orr
    Frontiers in Public Health.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • The current nature of police officer fatalities in Australia and opportunities for prevention
    Kelly A. Hine, Samantha Carey
    Current Issues in Criminal Justice.2021; 33(2): 191.     CrossRef
  • Relationship Between Metabolic Fitness and Performance in Police Occupational Tasks
    Elisa F. D. Canetti, J. Jay Dawes, Phoebe H. Drysdale, Robert Lockie, Charlie Kornhauser, Ryan Holmes, Ben Schram, Robin M. Orr
    Journal of Science in Sport and Exercise.2021; 3(2): 179.     CrossRef
  • Skeletal Muscle Mass and Fat Mass Relationships With Physical Fitness Test Performance in Law Enforcement Recruits Before Academy
    Robert G. Lockie, Blake N. Carlock, Tomas J. Ruvalcaba, Joseph M. Dulla, Robin M. Orr, J. Jay Dawes, Megan B. McGuire
    Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research.2021; 35(5): 1287.     CrossRef
  • Influence of Wearing Ballistic Vests on Physical Performance of Danish Police Officers: A Cross-Over Study
    Henrik Koblauch, Mette K. Zebis, Mikkel H. Jacobsen, Bjarki T. Haraldsson, Klaus P. Klinge, Tine Alkjær, Jesper Bencke, Lars L. Andersen
    Sensors.2021; 21(5): 1795.     CrossRef
  • The effects of fatiguing exercise and load carriage on the perception and initiation of movement
    Caleb D. Johnson, Shawn R. Eagle, Bradley C. Nindl, Mita T. Lovalekar, Shawn D. Flanagan, Gert-Jan Pepping, Christopher Connaboy
    European Journal of Sport Science.2021; 21(1): 36.     CrossRef
  • Relationships Between Heart Rate Variability, Occupational Performance, and Fitness for Tactical Personnel: A Systematic Review
    Colin Tomes, Ben Schram, Robin Orr
    Frontiers in Public Health.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Developing the Fitness of Law Enforcement Recruits during Academy Training
    Danny J. Maupin, Ben Schram, Elisa F. D. Canetti, Jay J. Dawes, Robert Lockie, Robin M. Orr
    Sustainability.2020; 12(19): 7944.     CrossRef
  • Methods for improving thermal tolerance in military personnel prior to deployment
    Edward Tom Ashworth, James David Cotter, Andrew Edward Kilding
    Military Medical Research.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • The physical competence test of the Dutch National Police: The effects of wearing a police uniform on test performance
    Matthijs Koedijk, Hessel F. Stuurman, Peter G. Renden, R.I. (Vana) Hutter, Marian Strating, Raôul R. D. Oudejans
    Police Practice and Research.2020; 21(3): 264.     CrossRef
  • Sustainable solutions to mitigate occupational heat strain – an umbrella review of physiological effects and global health perspectives
    Nathan B. Morris, Ollie Jay, Andreas D. Flouris, Ana Casanueva, Chuansi Gao, Josh Foster, George Havenith, Lars Nybo
    Environmental Health.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • The Interaction Between Physical and Psychosocial Stressors
    Esraa S. Abdelall, Zoe Eagle, Tor Finseth, Ahmad A. Mumani, Zhonglun Wang, Michael C. Dorneich, Richard T. Stone
    Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Ability of fitness testing to predict injury risk during initial tactical training: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Colin D Tomes, Sally Sawyer, Robin Orr, Ben Schram
    Injury Prevention.2020; 26(1): 67.     CrossRef
  • Association between Body Fat Percentage and Physical Performance in Male Korean Police Officers
    Jooyoung Kim, Wi-Young So, Sangwoon Kim
    Sustainability.2020; 12(9): 3868.     CrossRef
  • The effects of body armour on mobility and postural control of police officers
    Ben Schram, Robin Orr, Ben Hinton, Geoff Norris, Rodney Pope
    Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies.2020; 24(3): 190.     CrossRef
  • Effects of Personal Protective Equipment on the Performance of Federal Highway Policemen in Physical Fitness Tests
    Eduardo F. Marins, Leo Cabistany, Charles Bartel, Jay Dawes, Fabrício Boscolo Del Vecchio
    Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research.2020; 34(1): 11.     CrossRef
  • A Comparative Analysis of Physical Fitness in Korean Police Officers: Focus on Results between 2014 to 2019
    Sangwoon Kim, Jooyoung Kim
    Exercise Science.2019; 28(4): 396.     CrossRef
  • The effects of body armour on the power development and agility of police officers
    Ben Schram, Robin Orr, Ben Hinton, Rodney Pope, Geoff Norris
    Ergonomics.2019; 62(10): 1349.     CrossRef
  • Underwater space suit performance assessments part 2: Reach envelopes as a comparative performance metric
    K. Han Kim, Yaritza Hernandez, Elizabeth Benson, Sarah Jarvis, Ian Meginnis, Sudhakar Rajulu
    International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics.2019; 73: 102832.     CrossRef
  • The Impact of Backpack Loads on School Children: A Critical Narrative Review
    Michelle Perrone, Robin Orr, Wayne Hing, Nikki Milne, Rodney Pope
    International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2018; 15(11): 2529.     CrossRef
  • Effect of Load Carriage on Tactical Performance in Special Weapons and Tactics Operators
    Matthew Thomas, Michael B. Pohl, Robert Shapiro, Jason Keeler, Mark G. Abel
    Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research.2018; 32(2): 554.     CrossRef
  • Comparing the Effects of Different Body Armor Systems on the Occupational Performance of Police Officers
    Ben Schram, Robin Orr, Rodney Pope, Ben Hinton, Geoff Norris
    International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2018; 15(5): 893.     CrossRef
  • The perceived effects and comfort of various body armour systems on police officers while performing occupational tasks
    B. Schram, B. Hinton, R. Orr, R. Pope, G. Norris
    Annals of Occupational and Environmental Medicine.2018;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • 67 View
  • 1 Download
  • 47 Web of Science
  • 47 Crossref
Close layer

Ann Occup Environ Med : Annals of Occupational and Environmental Medicine
Close layer
TOP